ESG Investing in Emerging Markets: Frameworks and Best Practices

What Is ESG Investing?

ESG stands for Environmental, Social, and Governance. These are three key factors investors use to measure how sustainable and ethical a company or investment is.

Environmental factors look at how a company impacts nature. This includes carbon emissions, water use, waste management, and pollution control.

Social factors examine how a company treats people. This covers worker safety, labor rights, community relations, and product safety.

Governance factors assess how a company is run. This includes board independence, executive pay, shareholder rights, and business ethics.

ESG investing means choosing investments based on these criteria, not just financial returns. Investors believe companies with strong ESG practices are better long-term investments.

What Are Emerging Markets?

Emerging markets are countries with developing economies that are growing rapidly. They are not yet fully developed like the United States or Germany, but they are not poor countries either.

Common examples include China, India, Brazil, Mexico, Indonesia, South Africa, and Vietnam. These countries typically have younger populations, growing middle classes, and expanding industries.

Emerging markets often offer higher growth potential than developed countries. However, they also carry higher risks including political instability, currency fluctuations, and less developed legal systems.

These markets represent about 85% of the world's population. They account for roughly 60% of global GDP when measured by purchasing power.

Why ESG Matters in Emerging Markets

Emerging markets face some of the world's biggest environmental and social challenges. Climate change, water scarcity, air pollution, and labor rights issues are often more severe in these regions.

At the same time, these countries are building new infrastructure and industries. This creates opportunities to build sustainably from the start, rather than fixing old systems.

Many emerging market companies are improving ESG practices to attract foreign investment. International investors often require certain ESG standards before they will invest.

Strong ESG practices can help companies in emerging markets access cheaper capital. They can also improve operational efficiency and reduce risks from future regulations.

Key ESG Challenges in Emerging Markets

Limited Data Availability

Many emerging market companies do not publish detailed ESG reports. Reporting standards are often voluntary, not required by law.

When data exists, it may be incomplete or unreliable. Companies may lack the resources or expertise to measure and report ESG metrics accurately.

Independent verification of ESG claims is less common. Third-party audits and certifications are not always available or trusted.

Weaker Regulatory Frameworks

Environmental and labor laws in emerging markets are often less strict than in developed countries. Enforcement of existing laws may be inconsistent.

Corruption and weak governance can undermine environmental and social protections. Companies may be able to avoid compliance through unofficial channels.

Regulations are evolving rapidly in many countries. This creates uncertainty for investors trying to assess long-term ESG risks.

Different Cultural and Social Norms

What counts as good governance varies across cultures. For example, family-owned businesses are common and accepted in many emerging markets.

Labor practices that seem problematic to Western investors may be standard in local contexts. Understanding these differences requires cultural knowledge.

Stakeholder priorities differ by region. Communities may prioritize job creation over environmental protection in areas with high poverty.

Currency and Political Risks

Political instability can quickly change the ESG landscape. New governments may roll back environmental protections or labor rights.

Currency fluctuations can affect the real returns of ESG investments. A good ESG investment may lose value due to exchange rate changes.

Geopolitical tensions can impact specific sectors or countries. Trade disputes or sanctions may affect ESG-focused investments.

Major ESG Frameworks and Standards

Principles for Responsible Investment (PRI)

The PRI is a UN-supported initiative launched in 2006. It provides a framework for investors to incorporate ESG factors into investment decisions.

The PRI has six principles that guide responsible investing. These cover ESG integration, active ownership, disclosure, and collaboration.

Over 5,000 organizations worldwide have signed the PRI. Signatories commit to reporting on their ESG integration efforts annually.

The PRI framework works globally but requires adaptation for emerging markets. Investors must balance international standards with local realities.

Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB)

SASB develops industry-specific ESG disclosure standards. These standards identify which ESG issues are most financially material for each industry.

SASB covers 77 industries across 11 sectors. Each industry has specific ESG metrics that companies should report.

SASB standards are designed for investor decision-making. They focus on financially material information, not all possible ESG impacts.

In emerging markets, SASB provides a useful benchmark. However, many companies have not yet adopted these standards.

Global Reporting Initiative (GRI)

GRI is the most widely used sustainability reporting framework globally. It helps organizations report their impacts on the environment, society, and economy.

GRI standards are designed for all stakeholders, not just investors. They cover a broader range of impacts than investor-focused frameworks.

The framework is modular, allowing companies to report on relevant topics. Universal standards apply to all organizations, while topic-specific standards cover particular issues.

Many emerging market companies use GRI for their first sustainability reports. The framework provides clear guidance for organizations new to ESG reporting.

Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD)

TCFD focuses specifically on climate-related financial risks. It provides recommendations for how companies should disclose climate risks and opportunities.

The framework covers governance, strategy, risk management, and metrics related to climate. It asks companies to consider different climate scenarios.

TCFD is becoming mandatory in some developed markets. Emerging market companies exporting to these regions must increasingly comply.

Climate risks are particularly relevant in emerging markets. Many are more vulnerable to physical climate impacts like floods, droughts, and heat waves.

Local and Regional Standards

Some emerging markets have developed their own ESG frameworks. China has green bond standards and ESG disclosure guidelines for certain sectors.

India's Business Responsibility and Sustainability Reporting (BRSR) is mandatory for top-listed companies. This framework aligns with international standards while addressing local priorities.

Brazil, South Africa, and other countries have similar initiatives. These local frameworks often blend international best practices with domestic needs.

Investors should understand both global and local frameworks. This helps identify which standards apply and how compliance is measured.

How to Evaluate ESG Performance in Emerging Markets

Using ESG Rating Agencies

Several organizations rate companies on ESG performance. Major providers include MSCI, Sustainalytics, Refinitiv, and S&P Global.

These agencies collect data from company reports, news sources, and other databases. They score companies based on their methodologies.

ESG ratings for emerging market companies are often less reliable. Limited data means ratings may be based on incomplete information.

Different rating agencies can give very different scores to the same company. Investors should compare multiple ratings and understand each methodology.

Conducting On-the-Ground Research

Site visits and local research are especially important in emerging markets. Information from headquarters may not reflect conditions at factories or project sites.

Investors or their representatives should visit facilities when possible. This helps verify environmental practices, worker conditions, and community relations.

Engaging with local stakeholders provides valuable insights. NGOs, community groups, and labor unions can share information not available in company reports.

Independent local experts can help interpret ESG information. They understand cultural context and can identify red flags that foreign investors might miss.

Analyzing Available Financial Data

Financial statements can reveal ESG risks even without formal ESG reports. High employee turnover, frequent regulatory fines, or environmental liabilities indicate problems.

Capital expenditures on environmental equipment show commitment to sustainability. Comparing these investments across competitors provides context.

Legal proceedings and contingent liabilities sections may disclose ESG risks. Environmental lawsuits, labor disputes, or corruption investigations are warning signs.

Related party transactions can indicate governance issues. Excessive dealings with family members or unclear business relationships raise red flags.

Engaging with Company Management

Direct dialogue with companies helps clarify ESG practices. Investors can ask specific questions about policies, implementation, and future plans.

Management's responsiveness indicates governance quality. Companies with strong governance are transparent and willing to discuss challenges.

Engagement can drive ESG improvements over time. When investors collectively push for better practices, companies often respond.

Regular engagement meetings allow investors to track progress. This is especially valuable in emerging markets where public reporting may be limited.

Reviewing Third-Party Certifications

Certifications provide independent verification of certain ESG claims. Examples include ISO 14001 for environmental management and SA8000 for social accountability.

In emerging markets, certifications are valuable but not foolproof. Investors should verify the credibility of the certifying body.

Industry-specific certifications carry different weight. Fair Trade, Forest Stewardship Council, or LEED certifications address specific ESG aspects.

The absence of certifications doesn't necessarily mean poor ESG performance. Small companies may have good practices but lack resources for formal certification.

Best Practices for ESG Investing in Emerging Markets

Start with Clear ESG Objectives

Define what ESG means for your investment strategy. Different investors prioritize different ESG factors based on their values and risk tolerance.

Decide whether you want to exclude certain sectors or actively seek ESG leaders. Negative screening, positive screening, and engagement strategies serve different purposes.

Set measurable ESG goals alongside financial targets. This allows you to track whether investments are meeting both ESG and return objectives.

Align ESG objectives with investment time horizons. Long-term investors can better absorb short-term ESG transition costs for better future outcomes.

Diversify Across Countries and Sectors

Don't concentrate ESG investments in one emerging market. Political, regulatory, and economic risks vary significantly by country.

Different sectors face different ESG opportunities and challenges. Renewable energy, financial services, and healthcare often have strong ESG potential.

Balance between ESG leaders and improvers. Companies on an ESG improvement trajectory may offer better returns than those already at the top.

Consider both large and small companies. While large firms have better reporting, smaller companies may offer innovation and growth potential.

Prioritize Material ESG Issues

Focus on ESG factors that significantly impact financial performance. Not all ESG issues are equally important for every industry.

For mining companies, environmental and community relations are critical. For banks, governance and financial inclusion are more material.

Use frameworks like SASB to identify financially material ESG issues. This helps separate issues that affect returns from those that don't.

Be willing to look past immaterial ESG weaknesses. A company might score poorly on an ESG factor that doesn't affect its business model or risks.

Build Local Expertise

Hire or partner with people who understand local markets. Language skills, cultural knowledge, and on-the-ground presence are invaluable.

Develop relationships with local research providers and consultants. They can provide insights that global rating agencies miss.

Attend local conferences and industry events. This builds networks and provides firsthand understanding of ESG challenges and opportunities.

Train investment teams on regional differences in ESG practices. What works in Latin America may not apply in Southeast Asia.

Engage Actively with Portfolio Companies

Don't be a passive investor in emerging markets. Active engagement helps improve ESG practices and protects investment value.

Set clear expectations for ESG improvements over time. Work with companies to develop realistic roadmaps for addressing weaknesses.

Collaborate with other investors when possible. Collective engagement carries more weight than individual investor requests.

Be patient but persistent. ESG improvements take time, especially when companies are building capabilities from scratch.

Monitor Regulatory Developments

Track ESG-related policy changes in target markets. New environmental laws, labor regulations, or governance requirements can quickly impact investments.

Understand how international regulations affect emerging market companies. EU regulations on supply chains or carbon reporting can impact exporters globally.

Anticipate future regulatory trends. Countries often follow regional leaders, so understanding policy directions helps predict changes.

Join industry associations that track regulatory developments. Collective monitoring is more efficient than individual efforts.

Use Proxy Indicators When Data Is Limited

When direct ESG data is unavailable, use related indicators. Industry averages, peer comparisons, and indirect measures can fill gaps.

Country-level ESG metrics provide context. Understanding national environmental policies, labor laws, and governance norms helps assess company risks.

Track improvements over time rather than absolute scores. A company moving from poor to fair ESG performance may be a better investment than one stuck at good.

Combine quantitative and qualitative assessments. Numbers alone don't capture the full ESG picture in data-limited environments.

Consider Impact Investment Approaches

Impact investing explicitly targets measurable social or environmental benefits. This approach suits investors who prioritize ESG outcomes alongside returns.

Define impact metrics aligned with your goals. These might include carbon reduction, jobs created, or people gaining access to services.

Accept that deep impact may require return tradeoffs. Pure impact investments might offer below-market returns in exchange for greater ESG outcomes.

Blend impact and commercial investments in portfolios. This balances ESG ambitions with financial performance requirements.

Sector-Specific ESG Opportunities

Renewable Energy

Emerging markets lead global renewable energy growth. Countries like China, India, and Brazil are massive markets for solar, wind, and hydroelectric power.

These countries have abundant renewable resources. High solar radiation, strong winds, and large rivers provide natural advantages.

Government policies increasingly support renewables. Subsidies, tax incentives, and renewable energy targets create investment opportunities.

Infrastructure needs are enormous. Emerging markets must build power capacity to meet growing demand, providing opportunities for clean energy.

Financial Inclusion

Billions of people in emerging markets lack access to basic financial services. This represents both a social need and a business opportunity.

Digital financial services are expanding rapidly. Mobile banking and fintech companies reach previously unbanked populations.

Microfinance and small business lending have strong social impact. These services help lift people out of poverty while generating returns.

Insurance products protect vulnerable populations from shocks. Agricultural insurance, health coverage, and disaster protection fill critical gaps.

Sustainable Agriculture

Agriculture is central to many emerging economies. Improving sustainability in this sector has massive environmental and social impact.

Climate-smart agriculture techniques improve yields while reducing emissions. These methods help farmers adapt to climate change.

Supply chain traceability is increasing. Technology allows tracking of environmental and labor practices from farm to consumer.

Organic and sustainable farming practices are growing. Premium markets in developed countries create incentives for sustainable production.

Clean Water and Sanitation

Water scarcity affects billions in emerging markets. Investments in water treatment, distribution, and conservation are critical.

Wastewater treatment is often inadequate. Infrastructure investments can improve public health and reduce pollution.

Water efficiency technologies help industries reduce consumption. This lowers costs and environmental impact simultaneously.

Public-private partnerships create investment opportunities. Governments increasingly partner with private investors to build water infrastructure.

Affordable Healthcare

Healthcare access varies widely in emerging markets. Investments that expand affordable, quality care have strong ESG profiles.

Telemedicine and digital health tools reach remote areas. Technology makes healthcare more accessible without building expensive facilities.

Generic pharmaceuticals improve access to essential medicines. Local pharmaceutical companies produce affordable versions of life-saving drugs.

Preventive care and diagnostics reduce healthcare costs. Early detection and treatment prevent more expensive interventions later.

Sustainable Transportation

Urban transportation in emerging markets is often polluted and inefficient. Electric vehicles, public transit, and active transportation offer solutions.

Electric vehicle adoption is accelerating. China leads global EV production and sales, with other emerging markets following.

Bus rapid transit systems provide low-carbon urban mobility. Cities like Bogotá and Jakarta have developed successful BRT networks.

Bike-sharing and micro-mobility reduce emissions. These services are popular in dense urban areas across emerging markets.

Measuring ESG Impact and Returns

Setting Baselines and Targets

Establish baseline ESG metrics before investing. This allows you to measure improvements over time.

Set specific, measurable targets for ESG outcomes. Examples include reducing carbon intensity by 20% or improving worker safety scores.

Align targets with international frameworks when possible. The UN Sustainable Development Goals provide widely recognized benchmarks.

Balance ambition with realism. Targets should stretch companies to improve without being unachievable.

Tracking Key Performance Indicators

Identify 5-10 key ESG metrics for each investment. Focus on material issues that affect financial performance and impact.

Collect data regularly, at least annually. More frequent tracking helps identify problems early.

Compare performance against peers and industry benchmarks. Context helps determine whether performance is strong or weak.

Document data sources and methodology. This ensures consistency and allows verification of reported metrics.

Calculating Financial Returns

Analyze whether ESG investments generate competitive financial returns. Track performance against relevant market benchmarks.

Separate ESG effects from other factors affecting returns. This requires careful analysis since many variables influence performance.

Consider risk-adjusted returns, not just absolute returns. ESG investments may provide better downside protection during market stress.

Evaluate returns over appropriate time horizons. ESG benefits often materialize over years, not quarters.

Assessing Real-World Impact

Beyond financial returns, measure actual ESG outcomes. This includes tons of carbon reduced, workers protected, or communities benefited.

Use standardized impact metrics when available. Frameworks like IRIS+ help measure social and environmental impact consistently.

Verify impact claims through independent sources. Don't rely solely on company self-reporting.

Acknowledge limitations in measuring impact. Some ESG benefits are difficult to quantify precisely.

Reporting to Stakeholders

Provide transparent ESG reporting to clients and beneficiaries. This builds trust and demonstrates accountability.

Explain both successes and challenges honestly. Acknowledging problems shows integrity and allows learning.

Use clear, accessible language in reports. Avoid jargon that obscures understanding.

Share lessons learned with the broader investment community. This advances ESG investing practices overall.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Greenwashing and False Claims

Some companies exaggerate or fabricate ESG credentials. This is especially common where enforcement is weak.

Verify ESG claims through independent research. Don't accept company statements at face value.

Look for specific evidence of ESG practices. Vague sustainability commitments without details are red flags.

Be skeptical of sudden ESG improvements. Real change takes time and resources.

Applying Developed Market Standards Rigidly

Emerging market companies may not meet developed market ESG standards. This doesn't automatically make them bad investments.

Understand the context and trajectory of improvement. A company moving from poor to fair may have better prospects than a developed market company stuck at good.

Focus on direction of change, not just current state. Companies making genuine efforts to improve deserve credit.

Balance international standards with local realities. Some ESG expectations may be unrealistic given local conditions.

Overlooking Governance in Favor of E and S

Environmental and social factors often get more attention. However, governance affects whether E and S commitments are actually implemented.

Strong governance is foundational to ESG performance. Without good governance, environmental and social claims are unreliable.

Assess board quality, transparency, and shareholder rights. These governance factors predict whether companies will honor ESG commitments.

Look for alignment between management incentives and ESG goals. If executives aren't rewarded for ESG performance, it's unlikely to be a priority.

Ignoring Currency and Macro Risks

ESG investments in emerging markets still face currency risk. A strong ESG company can lose value due to currency depreciation.

Consider hedging currency risk when appropriate. This protects returns but adds cost and complexity.

Understand how macro conditions affect ESG priorities. Economic crises may cause governments to prioritize growth over environmental protection.

Diversify across currencies and economic cycles. This reduces dependence on any single country's economic performance.

Insufficient Due Diligence

Emerging market ESG investing requires more research than developed market investing. Shortcuts often lead to problems.

Budget adequate time and resources for due diligence. Thorough research costs money but prevents bigger losses.

Don't rely on a single information source. Cross-check data from multiple providers and verify through independent research.

Update due diligence regularly. Conditions in emerging markets can change rapidly.

The Future of ESG in Emerging Markets

Improving Data and Transparency

ESG disclosure requirements are expanding in emerging markets. More countries are mandating sustainability reporting for listed companies.

Technology is improving data collection and verification. Satellite monitoring, IoT sensors, and blockchain enable better ESG tracking.

International pressure for better disclosure continues. Companies wanting foreign investment must meet rising transparency expectations.

Standardization efforts are progressing. Initiatives like the International Sustainability Standards Board aim to harmonize ESG reporting globally.

Growing Investor Demand

Emerging market investors increasingly care about ESG. Domestic pension funds, insurance companies, and wealthy individuals are incorporating ESG criteria.

Younger generations prioritize sustainability. As wealth transfers to millennials and Gen Z, ESG demand will increase.

Sovereign wealth funds are integrating ESG. Major funds from emerging markets are adopting responsible investment principles.

ESG is becoming mainstream, not niche. What was once a specialized strategy is now standard practice for many investors.

Climate Adaptation and Resilience

Climate change impacts are already severe in many emerging markets. Investment in adaptation and resilience will grow substantially.

Infrastructure must be climate-resilient. New roads, buildings, and utilities should withstand expected climate impacts.

Agricultural adaptation is critical. Farmers need drought-resistant crops, efficient irrigation, and crop insurance.

Cities must prepare for climate risks. Flood protection, cooling systems, and emergency preparedness require investment.

Technology-Enabled ESG Solutions

Digital technologies enable ESG solutions that weren't previously possible. Blockchain, AI, and IoT create new opportunities.

Supply chain traceability improves with technology. Consumers and investors can verify environmental and labor practices.

Remote monitoring reduces the need for physical site visits. Satellites and sensors track environmental compliance in real time.

Big data and AI improve ESG analysis. Machine learning can identify patterns and risks in vast amounts of information.

Integration with Development Goals

ESG investing increasingly aligns with UN Sustainable Development Goals. This creates common language between investors, companies, and governments.

Development finance institutions partner with private investors. Blended finance structures make ESG investments more attractive.

Impact measurement ties to development outcomes. Investors can track how investments contribute to poverty reduction, education, or health.

ESG investing supports national development priorities. This alignment helps attract government support and reduces regulatory risk.

‍